There is Nothing to Celebrate
By
Evelyn Hecht-Galinski, Sicht
vom Hochblauen, 8 November 2017, English translation by Milena Rampoldi,
ProMosaik.
Evelyn Hecht-Galinski, Sicht
vom Hochblauen, 8 November 2017, English translation by Milena Rampoldi,
ProMosaik.
When
on 9 November for the 78th time we commemorate the Kristallnacht and
German politicians, together with Jewish officials, repeat slogans like “Never
again” . . . “The Holocaust is unique” . . . and “Against Oblivion”, then this remembrance
is meaningless because for the Palestinian people in occupied Jerusalem it is Crystal Night “Kristallnacht” almost
every night!
on 9 November for the 78th time we commemorate the Kristallnacht and
German politicians, together with Jewish officials, repeat slogans like “Never
again” . . . “The Holocaust is unique” . . . and “Against Oblivion”, then this remembrance
is meaningless because for the Palestinian people in occupied Jerusalem it is Crystal Night “Kristallnacht” almost
every night!
How can we celebrate this remembrance day without thinking
about the actual illegal situation in Palestine? How is it possible that in
German education we correctly talk about the Holocaust as one of the greatest
crimes of humanity and then completely ignore the crimes committed in
Palestine? Nothing is further from my intentions than the relativisation of
Nazi crimes, but it takes the breath out of me, when I see how the descendants
of the victims of this Shoah crime justify today’s injustice with the injustice
of that time. Injustice can never be justified, and there is no excuse for this
behaviour.
about the actual illegal situation in Palestine? How is it possible that in
German education we correctly talk about the Holocaust as one of the greatest
crimes of humanity and then completely ignore the crimes committed in
Palestine? Nothing is further from my intentions than the relativisation of
Nazi crimes, but it takes the breath out of me, when I see how the descendants
of the victims of this Shoah crime justify today’s injustice with the injustice
of that time. Injustice can never be justified, and there is no excuse for this
behaviour.
I can only repeat myself and say that I cannot keep silent
in the face of this injustice, and this is what I learnt from my father who is
an Auschwitz survivor. When he decided to come back to Berlin to re-build
Jewish life in Germany, he was opposed to Israel. And his life’s motto also
became the motivating force of my actions: “I have not survived Auschwitz to
keep silent about new injustice.” I do not keep silent about the crimes
committed today by a “Jewish State” that justifies them with the Holocaust.
in the face of this injustice, and this is what I learnt from my father who is
an Auschwitz survivor. When he decided to come back to Berlin to re-build
Jewish life in Germany, he was opposed to Israel. And his life’s motto also
became the motivating force of my actions: “I have not survived Auschwitz to
keep silent about new injustice.” I do not keep silent about the crimes
committed today by a “Jewish State” that justifies them with the Holocaust.
And what is even worse: Germany is driven by a misunderstood
feelings of guilt and solidarises with these crimes. And this way the old guilt
just becomes a new guilt they will never be able to make amends for.
feelings of guilt and solidarises with these crimes. And this way the old guilt
just becomes a new guilt they will never be able to make amends for.
The old German Republic of Adenauer, Oberländer, and Globke,
the “commentator” of the race and aryanization laws, and the
epoch of the “nice, brown” FDP Meinde were interfused by old Nazis, who were
appointed as officials because they were needed, and then influenced the
country until the 1970s. They had taken back their official positions thanks to
an “anti-nazifization certificate” issued by the Allies.
I remember my father struggling for his recognition as persecuted person first
and then as Jewish official to be heard by German politicians and media.
the “commentator” of the race and aryanization laws, and the
epoch of the “nice, brown” FDP Meinde were interfused by old Nazis, who were
appointed as officials because they were needed, and then influenced the
country until the 1970s. They had taken back their official positions thanks to
an “anti-nazifization certificate” issued by the Allies.
I remember my father struggling for his recognition as persecuted person first
and then as Jewish official to be heard by German politicians and media.
It was also at that time that the USA was involved in the
War in Korea and the Germans were used as a constant bulwark during the Cold
War, a situation that has remained unchanged to today.
War in Korea and the Germans were used as a constant bulwark during the Cold
War, a situation that has remained unchanged to today.
I still remember very well how in 1947 my father helped to
accommodate former KZ prisoners and Jewish repatriates in empty houses. This
very day, this motivated the “steel helmet Jew,”
the former Bundeswehr Professor Michael Wolffsohn to persecute Heinz Galinski
by his “romanticised”
grandfather and home owners in various books with “hate over generations.”
Wolffsohn tried anything to discredit my father, but fortunately he did not
succeed.
accommodate former KZ prisoners and Jewish repatriates in empty houses. This
very day, this motivated the “steel helmet Jew,”
the former Bundeswehr Professor Michael Wolffsohn to persecute Heinz Galinski
by his “romanticised”
grandfather and home owners in various books with “hate over generations.”
Wolffsohn tried anything to discredit my father, but fortunately he did not
succeed.
I also felt attracted by the so called 68s, and turned away
from the mendacity of certain politicians and parties. For me, the ‘German
Autumn’ was the dawning of a new age. In particular in Berlin this sentiment
was a glimmer of hope in times of “Springer’s
incitement press.” Rudi Dutschke was
a stroke of luck for us even if he had no idea against this system. And I was
also attracted by young engaged people interested in Palestine turning away
from the guilt-ridden solidarity with Israel. Yes, we rose up and did not want
to be involved in the Nazi-guilt anymore while old Nazis were still present at
universities and in ministries.
from the mendacity of certain politicians and parties. For me, the ‘German
Autumn’ was the dawning of a new age. In particular in Berlin this sentiment
was a glimmer of hope in times of “Springer’s
incitement press.” Rudi Dutschke was
a stroke of luck for us even if he had no idea against this system. And I was
also attracted by young engaged people interested in Palestine turning away
from the guilt-ridden solidarity with Israel. Yes, we rose up and did not want
to be involved in the Nazi-guilt anymore while old Nazis were still present at
universities and in ministries.
In fact, Yassir Arafat was a hero for me and is a hero up to
now, as opposed to his actual successors like President Abbas.
now, as opposed to his actual successors like President Abbas.
On 2 November, when the British Prime Minister May and her
colleague Netanyahu celebrated the 100th anniversary of the Balfour Declaration
during a festive dinner, you could only feel disgusted by these celebrations.
The leader of the opposition Jeremy Corbyn did the only right thing and refused
to participate by declining the invitation. It is a sad fact that in Great Britain
and in the “Jewish State” the foundation of a national home for the Jewish
people was celebrated, while the displacement of hundreds of thousands of
Palestinians from their homeland and the actual misery of millions of
Palestinians were simply ignored. And this event was the foundation of the myth
of the “Jewish people” by declaring that the religious Jewish community is a
Jewish “people” to legitimise the “national Jewish home.” This way also the
horrifying dream of the Jewish State of Theodor Herzl and the “modern” solution of
the Jewish question were realised.
colleague Netanyahu celebrated the 100th anniversary of the Balfour Declaration
during a festive dinner, you could only feel disgusted by these celebrations.
The leader of the opposition Jeremy Corbyn did the only right thing and refused
to participate by declining the invitation. It is a sad fact that in Great Britain
and in the “Jewish State” the foundation of a national home for the Jewish
people was celebrated, while the displacement of hundreds of thousands of
Palestinians from their homeland and the actual misery of millions of
Palestinians were simply ignored. And this event was the foundation of the myth
of the “Jewish people” by declaring that the religious Jewish community is a
Jewish “people” to legitimise the “national Jewish home.” This way also the
horrifying dream of the Jewish State of Theodor Herzl and the “modern” solution of
the Jewish question were realised.
Lord Lionel Walter Rothschild, the Zionist poster child of
Great Britain, praised the agreement as the “greatest event” in the Jewish
history of the last 1800 years. Did Rothschild buy his political future thanks
to the support by Balfour and was the declaration the reward?
Great Britain, praised the agreement as the “greatest event” in the Jewish
history of the last 1800 years. Did Rothschild buy his political future thanks
to the support by Balfour and was the declaration the reward?
While the Arabs trusted in the British promise of 1915 as
bulwark against the Ottoman Empire, and hoped to be awarded with a national
Arab state, the Balfour Declaration gave Palestine to Zionism as a national
home for the Jews. Today we have the same phenomenon: the “Jewish State” is the
bulwark of the West in the Middle East which should defend the
“Jewish-Christian values” against Islam.
bulwark against the Ottoman Empire, and hoped to be awarded with a national
Arab state, the Balfour Declaration gave Palestine to Zionism as a national
home for the Jews. Today we have the same phenomenon: the “Jewish State” is the
bulwark of the West in the Middle East which should defend the
“Jewish-Christian values” against Islam.
The Balfour Declaration consisted of only 67 words, and
their woolly formulation left room for Zionist interpretations resulting in the
actual illegal occupation, ethnical cleansing, and the “modern
final solution”
of the Palestine question. From the beginning, the rights of the “existing non-Jewish
communities in Palestine” were violated. In the end, the British colonialists
had exactly the same ideas like the Jewish colonialists. These Zionists should
get the chance to “civilise” the Arab population. I experienced this attitude
myself during my visits in Israel, when Jewish guides or friends spoke
disparagingly of the “dirty Arabs.” It was that Jewish disrespect towards the
Palestinians I started to hate at that time.
their woolly formulation left room for Zionist interpretations resulting in the
actual illegal occupation, ethnical cleansing, and the “modern
final solution”
of the Palestine question. From the beginning, the rights of the “existing non-Jewish
communities in Palestine” were violated. In the end, the British colonialists
had exactly the same ideas like the Jewish colonialists. These Zionists should
get the chance to “civilise” the Arab population. I experienced this attitude
myself during my visits in Israel, when Jewish guides or friends spoke
disparagingly of the “dirty Arabs.” It was that Jewish disrespect towards the
Palestinians I started to hate at that time.
Great Britain should apologise for this disaster, instead of
celebrating it. In fact, the Balfour Declaration became the foundation of the
ethnic cleansing and illegal occupation of Palestine. Lord Balfour, the former
British Foreign Minister, is present everywhere in the “Jewish State.” Almost
all former Palestinian villages, located in the illegally occupied Palestine,
have their Balfour Square or Street, while the original Arabic names were
effaced by the Zionists. So there was not just a physical, but also a cultural
and ethnic cleansing, increasing up to now. In fact, the Netanyahu regime also
tries to upstage the Arabic language.
celebrating it. In fact, the Balfour Declaration became the foundation of the
ethnic cleansing and illegal occupation of Palestine. Lord Balfour, the former
British Foreign Minister, is present everywhere in the “Jewish State.” Almost
all former Palestinian villages, located in the illegally occupied Palestine,
have their Balfour Square or Street, while the original Arabic names were
effaced by the Zionists. So there was not just a physical, but also a cultural
and ethnic cleansing, increasing up to now. In fact, the Netanyahu regime also
tries to upstage the Arabic language.
The false promises contrived in the secret Sykes Picot
Agreement by the British and French were reinforced in the Balfour Declaration.
However, today the decisive sentence is simply ignored: “It being clearly
understood that nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and
religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine.“
Agreement by the British and French were reinforced in the Balfour Declaration.
However, today the decisive sentence is simply ignored: “It being clearly
understood that nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and
religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine.“
All events after the Holocaust are inseparably linked to the
foundation of the “Jewish State” in 1948. The Balfour Declaration was the
beginning of the Nakba, the catastrophe for the Palestinian people. The
Palestinian people have never been compensated up to now for the crimes of the
displacement and confiscation of their property and lands. The “Jewish State”
has proven to be totally incapable of living in peace, supported by the
hypocritical community of states. An apology for the injustice would be a
small, first step on the path to the recognition of Palestine within
1967-borders. However, these steps seem to be as far away as peace. So what
remains is only the hope for a future justice in a common state of Palestine
for all its inhabitants, ethnic and religious groups.
foundation of the “Jewish State” in 1948. The Balfour Declaration was the
beginning of the Nakba, the catastrophe for the Palestinian people. The
Palestinian people have never been compensated up to now for the crimes of the
displacement and confiscation of their property and lands. The “Jewish State”
has proven to be totally incapable of living in peace, supported by the
hypocritical community of states. An apology for the injustice would be a
small, first step on the path to the recognition of Palestine within
1967-borders. However, these steps seem to be as far away as peace. So what
remains is only the hope for a future justice in a common state of Palestine
for all its inhabitants, ethnic and religious groups.
This should not be forgotten during the celebration of the
78th anniversary of the Kristallnacht and the Balfour Declaration of 100 years
ago. A memory without these thoughts would be an empty ritual which is not in
keeping with the times!
78th anniversary of the Kristallnacht and the Balfour Declaration of 100 years
ago. A memory without these thoughts would be an empty ritual which is not in
keeping with the times!
Until then there will be nothing to CELEBRATE!
